I have been waiting for this episode. Growing up in Indianapolis, I've heard of this case my entire life. My interest in this case took off in 2008, when I learned that my children's paternal grandparents knew some of the kids in the neighborhood and that their grandma's brother knew Sylvia's sister, Diana. It's a hell of a story, and I wish it were only a work of fiction, not the fate of a young girl in the prime of her life.
The Sunday before I began recording the episode, I decided to visit her grave. I bought a small bouquet of flowers (the yellow lillies called out to me) to take for her. She's buried in Oak Hill Cemetary in Lebanon, IN, a small town just north west of Indianapolis off of I-65. Following a map I'd found from the website sylvialikens.com, I found her grave. I grabbed the flowers and walked up to her grave, which is not far from the street. Her headstone was easy to spot as someone had left a small pot of fake flowers, which also had yellow lillies! Someone had left a rock that says you are loved and change all around her name. It was very sweet. I sat down and began to talk. Then I began to cry. For an hour.
So you can put names to faces, here are some of the photos of those involved:
As she was found the day she died.
Jenny and Betty Likens sitting with Prosecutor Leroy New
Diana, Sylvia and Jenny's older sister
Gertrude Baniszewski after her arrest.
Gertrude during her second trial. Notice the difference. Prison was good to her. She got three hots and a cot, something even Sylvia didn't get.
Gertrude after her release from prison. She should have died in there.
Stephanie Baniszewski
Shirley Baniszewski
Marie Baniszewski
John Baniszewski, Jr.
Coy Hubbard as a young man, and an old man.
Ricky Hobbs
The house at 3850 E. New York St. Inside the house, an absolute mess.
The Sylvia Likens Memorial in Willard Park
The Advocacy Center in Lebanon:
More photos:
Jenny and Leroy New
Map of Oak Hill Cemetery and the location of Sylvia's grave.
Thanks for listening! Tune in next time for Episode #6 - "Family Annihilators"
Don't be a dick!